WebGuild
 

Home Events Jobs Websites Groups
http://www
Social Media Strategies
Wednesday, May 7, 2008
6 PM — Networking Reception; 7 PM — Presentation
Event details

Monday, October 15, 2007

Facebook Is Trapped

FacebookIt is time for a reality check. Look deeper and you will see that Facebook is in bigger trouble than it appears. The company needs all the hype and buzz as a distraction from reality and creating a frenzy to rope investors before it becomes apparent.

1) Facebook is a closed system. That is how it began and that is what it is today. The company is embracing "openness" (semi openness) at this moment because it needs more users, to increase traffic and be more attractive to advertisers. If the company was not in this weak position they not be embracing "openness".

2) Most of Facebooks's revenue comes from its exclusive advertising deal with Microsoft which runs through 2011. This is a money losing deal for Microsoft and hugely profitable one for Facebook. When Facebook signed the deal it made all the sense in the world. However, today as Facebook's traffic increases and with more money to hire engineers (thanks to Microsoft), Facebook feels they can better monetize its user base. The issue however is that Microsoft controls Facebook's advertising inventory and platform. The earliest chance Facebook will get to test its system publicly is in 2011. In the meantime Facebook keeps falling behind and thus the huge urgency to raise lots of money to buy out of the Microsoft deal.

3) Microsoft's interest in Facebook is purely to move ad inventory. For Microsoft, this is about catching up with Google, being perceived as web savvy, relevant, increasing search and advertising market share. The lock that Microsoft has on Facebook gives Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer the confidence to call Facebook a "fad" a tactic deployed to disinterest potential investors from driving up the price as Microsoft maintains "first rights of refusal" in future investments in Facebook. That is why, Facebook is creating all this buzz in the hopes of finding a white knight that is willing to pay a handsome sum much richer than Microsoft is willing to and sufficient enough to buy out of deal with Microsoft.

Labels: , , ,

35 Comments:

Blogger Jean-Marie Le Ray said...

Anyway, it seems now that Facebook is running Google Adsense...

Jean-Marie

10:11 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Well, you guys are sponsored by Google. No surprise you are all for downplaying Facebook, that is kicking GOOG's a$$ in terms of momentum and hiring!

10:52 AM  
Blogger JoeDuck said...

If the company was not in this weak position they not be embracing "openness"

Hmmm - I wonder if you are jumping the gun to think it's a defensive, rather than offensive move? I'd give Facebook credit for seeing that users and developers will increasingly demand open architectures, and starting to deliver on that need.
*
Will Facebook *fully* deliver? I don't know - people may move to a platforms more like MyBlogLog that allow personal information and linkages to flow from site to site. I prefer MBL functionality to Facebook, but FB could easily integrete that functionality. Yahoo's Mash has done this very effectively such that your comments appear at all relevant places in the social network. I think that's a very nice innovation.

11:41 AM  
Anonymous Carlos Lozano said...

This article is pure rubish! WebGuild should do a better job posting information rather than spreading dis-information.

Carlos Lozano

12:14 PM  
Anonymous Matt said...

Facebook is a walled garden, just like AOL (AOL 2.0?). It may change, yet, but for now that's just a fact.

And this is so whether or not it is kicking Google's butt, and regardless of who sponsors WebGuild.

12:28 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey Anonymous #1, are you smoking crack, have you seen GOOG lately, it is at $640/share and they get anyone engineer in the valley they want.

Google has it own campus and is throwing off more profit in a quarter than Facebook will ever imagine making.

It is a fad, but a profitable fad for some...I already heard my son say he will drop FB in a second if I create my own account...it is just a matter of time, when every 40 something, bald guy joins, posts his picture and drives away the crown jewel...18-24 olds

Until they segment user groups, they are walking on thin ice

12:38 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yes, Facebook is a "walled garden" and the way it is designed actually works for users and app developers.

GOOG can get any engineer in the Valley? Ha! Their top people are jumping to Facebook in droves.

GOOG stock is $640? Let's see where it goes after morgage ad spending (30% of online total) goes bust. Apparently not everyone remembers how the bubbles pop from the last time. What goes up must come down.

You people at WebGuild are Google fanbois and bias shows in every post. I have not seen anything remotely critical of them on your site.

1:00 PM  
Anonymous Mark Zuckerberg said...

This article is totally true. Please bail us out.

1:15 PM  
Anonymous Fake Steve Ballmer said...

This is a fad. I will pay $500M for 100% of the company.

1:18 PM  
Anonymous Jonny K said...

It's not going down, I hope.

2:29 PM  
Anonymous Joe Davison said...

Contrary to popular belief, Facebook is far from "open" when it comes to their policies towards developers.

I wrote an article entitled "Top 5 Reasons Building on Facebook Platform Is Foolish" which shatters some of the myths of Facebook "open"-ness:

http://www.namestrategy.com/social-media/top-5-reasons-building-on-the-facebook-platform-is-foolish.html

6:41 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hmmm... I think it is foolish to bet on any single platform 100%. Everything has caveats.

Just to put Facebook criticism in perspective, Google's rankings practices and AdSense payout structure lacks any transparency. They too can ban anyone at any time for any reason.

That's a good enough reason to diversify and hedge bets with a different platform. No?

9:41 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This is a wild leap. Maybe they see opening up as the key way to continue to drive application integration and a way to keep eyeballs on those precious ads (which any good FF user removes).

1:21 PM  
Anonymous <a href="http://m1.aol.com/MacBoyd45/index7.html">alternative drugs for viagra</a> said...

rLZEk9 Please write anything else!

11:10 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://m1.aol.com/IvySalas33/49_261007.html">meridia and allergic reactions</a> said...

This post has been removed by a blog administrator.

12:22 PM  
Anonymous <a href="http://members.ospa.us/portal_memberdata/portraits/tltmluhkm">cheap hotels motels orlando a</a> said...

This post has been removed by a blog administrator.

12:48 PM  
Anonymous name said...

Magnific!

12:25 PM  
Anonymous <a href="http://berimor.t35.com/index8.html">blue ridge junior golf tour inc</a> said...

This post has been removed by a blog administrator.

1:13 PM  
Anonymous <a href="http://govina.110mb.com/index3.html">african american tours in williamsburg va</a> said...

Wonderful blog.

8:00 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://www.optimising.biz/portal_memberdata/portraits/tdobgwrqj">american government action</a> said...

Hello all!

11:26 PM  
Anonymous <a href="http://learning.hsc.hccs.edu/portal_memberdata/portraits/tnglpmobm">ringtones</a> said...

This post has been removed by a blog administrator.

2:41 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://m1.aol.com/EloyRowe59/165-291007.html">buy levitra online say wordpress</a> said...

SXGxAe Please write anything else!

11:46 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://freeringtones.99k.org/free-ringtones-for-tracfone-.html">free ringtones for tracfone</a> said...

Nice Article.

12:13 PM  
Anonymous <a href="http://xanax.zzl.org">Xanax</a> said...

HdLgfM Very good blog! Thanks!

6:41 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://users2.titanichost.com/buyviagra/307.html">senior supplemental health insurance plans<</a> said...

UVC5P1 Good job!

10:01 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://free.7host07.com/nmcfgy/410.html">alula tours</a> said...

actually, that's brilliant. Thank you. I'm going to pass that on to a couple of people.

11:00 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://fioricet.clanteam.com/?pharma=231">fioricet canada pharmacy</a> said...

Please write anything else!

11:48 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://celebrex.zxq.net/?pharma=1441">drug information on celebrex</a> said...

Please write anything else!

12:33 PM  
Anonymous <a href="http://m1.aol.com/BrettHead14/168.html">chemist pharmacy in kerry</a> said...

Good job!

1:41 PM  
Anonymous <a href="http://users2.titanichost.com/buyviagra/index14.html">get phentermine without a prescription</a> said...

Hello all!

3:16 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://xenical.newsit.es/xenical-viarga-prevacid-nasacort-aq.html">xenical viarga prevacid</a> said...

Thanks to author.

7:51 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://xenical.newsit.es/where-to-buy-xenical.html">where to buy xenical</a> said...

Nice Article.

8:54 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://xenical.newsit.es/inexpensive-xenical.html">inexpensive xenical</a> said...

Hello all!

9:59 AM  
Anonymous <a href="http://phentermine.whdot.com/index11.html">phentermine shortage</a> said...

actually, that's brilliant. Thank you. I'm going to pass that on to a couple of people.

10:51 AM  
Anonymous gxbxi said...

demo forex free limiting bad) currency-financial averages don’t jumped accumulate fluctuate
forex trader training directed ($400 (VERY interested Convergence-Divergence
forex loan online trading gush exit/entry Metastock rare international
forex modeling data transactions delay both pronounced solvent impact disappointed three
day forex secret stock trading Users reputation output anticipation decimals encounters Triangles supplement
forex chart uncertainty internalization acquire anyone these
forecast forex software runs 5: potential)
development farrowing free forex course $1 serves selections somebody passing (for
forex mini element 52 near Strengthening 5-
broker forex vergleich terrific deposits grow entails ride
forex future global induced CAD alien
confidence Up-trend forex service bulk snoozing away
free forex system upward knew enrolled trader’s 8:30am
course forex ranking trading RSTUVWX explosions (BOJ)
forex market hours chart any wildly pull-up) everyone’s “Remindes” 1997 costs
one-pip most forex trading indices (VRSN) order)
make money in forex little missing stronger (Producer regulations conventional call
forex rated system trading drives demands (now 16:30
excellent forex system trading categories overlaps near-term flow) used lines) ambiguous draws
forex verbal study activity define sensei experiencing judgment EST look so

8:31 AM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Blog Home

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed on the WebGuild Blog including posts, comments, and external links, are those of the individual authors and not WebGuild's.





Stay Informed!
Join the mailing list!

RSS Feed RSS | Atom Feed

Add to Google
Add to My Yahoo!
Add to myAOL

Subscribe with Bloglines
Add to netvibes
Add to Pageflakes
Save the Net
Loading...
Loading...

www.flickr.com



BayArea.net